What we found
A written estimate the next morning
Rob from our team visited on July 22, 2026, walked around the house and photographed every side. The next morning he had the roof measured and emailed a written estimate for a new Class 3 roof. It listed new decking and new gutters as options.
What we recommended
A full re-deck, not an overlay
The homeowner signed a revised estimate on August 26. The job order called for a full re-deck, not an overlay: the old decking comes off down to the rafters and new decking goes over the whole roof, instead of new sheets going over the old ones. It also called for ice and water shield along the eaves and rakes.
For shingles, the homeowner went with Malarkey Highlander AR in Natural Wood, a Class 3 impact-rated shingle. The gutter option wasn't chosen.
The tricky part
Opening the roof to the rafters
With the old decking off, the attic is open to the sky. The crew stripped and re-decked one section at a time on a clear, dry day, and had underlayment going down by midday.
Install day
New decking, one section at a time
Materials arrived on September 21, and the crew started the next morning. They were on the roof by 8:30 am, with tarps down on the lawn.
By 9:30, with plywood over the windows to protect the glass, the old decking was coming off down to the rafters and new decking was going on, one section at a time. By 10:45 one whole side was covered in new decking, by 12:30 the ice and water shield and underlayment were going down, and by 1 pm the first shingles were going on.
The result
All-new decking and a signed 10-year warranty
The finished roof was photographed on September 29: Natural Wood shingles over all-new decking. Rob signed the homeowner's written 10-year workmanship warranty that day. It can be transferred once if the house sells.
More about roofing in Verdigris, or how our roof replacement works, from the free inspection to the cleanup.
What you can take from this job
- Ask how your estimate handles decking, the boards under the shingles. Here, new decking was an option on the first estimate and part of the final job.
- A re-deck takes the old decking off down to the rafters; an overlay lays new sheets over the old ones. Ask which one you're paying for.
- A full re-deck goes one section at a time: this crew was on the roof by 8:30 am and laying shingles by 1 pm.




