What we found
Steep upper roofs under big trees
The house sits under big trees, and its upper roofs are steep. That meant safety ropes for the crew and extra care around the lawn, beds and big windows below.
What we recommended
Two estimates side by side, and the owner chose Class 4
On July 21 Wayne sent a written estimate for a Class 3 impact-resistant roof. Three days later he sent a second one with Class 3 and Class 4 side by side.
At the end of July the homeowner signed for the Class 4 roof, Malarkey Vista AR in Weathered Wood Plus, with high-profile hip and ridge caps. A solar attic fan on the estimate was left off. On this house the Class 4 roof cost $2,289 more than the Class 3 roof.
The tricky part
Steep slopes and new decking
The roof came down to new decking, and the upper roofs are steep. The crew worked tied off with safety ropes and was still at it past 8 PM, by porch light.
Install day
From 7:55 AM to past 8 PM, by porch light
On roof day the crew tore off the old roof, put down new decking, covered it with Malarkey underlayment and shingled the house. Wayne's photos start at 7:55 AM, and the last one, at 8:03 PM, shows the crew finishing over the front porch by porch light.
Tarps covered the lawn and beds, and plywood stood over the big ground-floor windows to protect the glass while the old roof came off.
The result
Class 4 shingles and high-profile caps
The finished roof is Malarkey Vista AR in Weathered Wood Plus, with high-profile caps on the hips and ridges, finished on roof day. The house also has 292 feet of new painted gutters with 9 downspouts, which aren’t part of the signed price.
More about roofing in Tulsa and roofing in south Tulsa, or how our roof replacement works, from the free inspection to the cleanup.
What you can take from this job
- Rotten decking (the boards under the shingles) usually shows up at tear-off. A good crew photographs it, tells you and replaces the bad boards before the new roof goes on.
- Seeing Class 3 and Class 4 prices side by side makes the choice easier, and Class 4 shingles may lower your insurance premium.
- Ask how the crew will protect your lawn, beds and windows during tear-off; on this house it was tarps and plywood.





