What we found
Two written estimates, Class 3 and Class 4
Wayne from our team inspected the house on September 4, 2026, photographing it from the yard and from up on the roof. He had the roof measured, and on September 8 he emailed the homeowner two written estimates: one for a Class 3 impact-rated roof and one for a Class 4.
What we recommended
The homeowner chose Class 4
The Class 4 estimate came to $1,190 more than the Class 3 one. The homeowner signed the Class 4 estimate the next day, September 9.
The Class 4 roof is Malarkey Vista AR, here in Black Oak, and a Class 4 roof may lower your insurance premium. The job order also called for ice and water shield on the lower slope and keeping the existing gutters.
The tricky part
Bad decking under the old shingles
You can't see decking until the old roof is off. Here, seven sheets needed replacing. The crew swapped them out the same day, and Wayne wrote the change up for the homeowner before the final invoice went out.
Install day
Seven new sheets of decking, the same day
Install day was September 21. The crew was tearing off by 8 am, with tarps covering the yard.
Once the old shingles were off, some of the decking needed replacing, so the crew cut out the bad sections and put in seven new sheets. By 10:30 the synthetic underlayment was going on at the back, and by mid-afternoon shingles were on the two-story section and going up the front slope, and the roof was finished that day.
The result
Before and after from the same spot
The finished roof was photographed the next morning from about the same spot as the inspection photo, so the before and after line up. The existing gutters stayed on the house, and the strip on the new shingles reads: Complies with UL 2218, Class 4.
More about roofing in Claremore, or how our roof replacement works, from the free inspection to the cleanup.
What you can take from this job
- Ask for Class 3 and Class 4 prices side by side. On this roof, Class 4 cost $1,190 more.
- Bad decking only shows once the old shingles are off. We photograph it, tell you and replace the bad boards.
- A Class 4 impact-rated roof may lower your insurance premium. Ask your agent before you choose.





